On the other hand, I know several people who seem like they have an axe to grind. I am not accusing anyone in particular, just pointing out the multiple bizarre similarities and things that give me pause. An Associated Press report from March 1997 stated that McReynolds and his wife, Janet, were initially questioned less than six weeks after the murder. (Bill McReynolds), He visited adult book stores and admitted to having a long-withstanding admiration for porn. I was in my 20s when she was murdered and am strongly IDI. A. James Kolar, who led the case investigation for the Boulder DAs office for nine months, believes its unlikely the girl was killed by an intruder. Where is this info coming from? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The South Carolina native got engaged over the weekend to Kendall McReynolds, daughter of two-time Daytona 500 winning-crew chief and NASCAR on FOX analyst Larry Another was Michael Helgoth, an electrician who worked at a nearby auto salvage yard. So who is Bill McReynolds? According to a 1999 New York Post article, McReynolds was a retired journalism professor and a close friend of the Ramseys. They didn't follow procedure with the nail clippers. John and other family members were cleared of suspicion through a handwriting test, but police couldnt conclusively determine if Patsy wrote the letter. JBR doesn't know the guy so it's not like there is some risk. Yet, when the case was reopened in 2009, the intruder theory was brought once again as a possible option. Thankful that God blessed me with such an amazing woman in my life that not only loves the Lord, but challenges me to be a better man. They were never charged as suspects in the murder. Burke is woken up and questioned. Then there is the statement from the mother of a friend of JonBents. To see all content on The Sun, please use the Site Map. Hired by Marilyn Haus to play Santa at the mall. Bill McReynolds dressed as Father Christmas to attend a party just days before the little girl was found murdered on Boxing Day 1996. However, it was revealed two weeks later that his DNA did not match the evidence found on JonBents clothing and he was released. Marionumber1 John and other family members were cleared of suspicion through a handwriting test, but police couldnt conclusively determine if Patsy wrote the letter. But they also know that he couldn't have written the note and they know that neither one of them wrote it or did anything wrong because they were together the entire time. Other suspects included neighbor Bill McReynolds, a local Santa Claus who visited the Ramseys a few days before the girls death. Well that's not surprising since anyone around back then would have been exposed to a massive amount "RDI" media spin. Have you read The Greenland Theory? DeMuth confronted Santa Bill, convinced that the cord being used to lash down a tarpaulin was like the cord used in the murder garrote. Unless Burke had a behavior disorder, why would they even think that anyone would consider him a suspect? Here are just a few of the stranger ones. Maybe that family member enlists a friend to do it instead so that police wouldn't quickly make the connection and unbeknonst to them, that friend is a creep, so things go horribly wrong and turn from kidnapping to murder. Can I ask you Ivy, did you live through the whole JonBenet murder saga as an adult while it was unfolding? John Mark Karr confessed to murdering JonBent in 2006. Dec 26, 1996. McReynolds won a Western States Art Foundation regional prize and a $7,500 grant from the National Endowment for the Arts, but it was never published and no copy has been released to the media since. He grew his long natural white beard when cast as a tavern owner in the play, "Les Miserables" for Unity of Boulder Church. Email us at exclusive@the-sun.com or call 212 416 4552. JonBent Ramsey was 6 years old when she was murdered in her Boulder, CO home on Christmas night 1996. Even more harrowing, Inside Edition reports that when Oliva was previously arrested in 2000, he was allegedly carrying a photograph of the child beauty queen with him, along with a copy of a poem he'd written called, "Ode to JonBent. Barry Williams/Getty Images News/Getty Images, Janet McReynolds wrote a play about a young girl, sexual assault was a factor in the murder. Stop it already". It was nearly 20 years ago when the mysterious JonBent Ramsey murder case shocked, and mortified people around the world. web pages IIRC, It was tinsel or part of a garland that was found in her hair, not glitter. were officially cleared of any involvement in the murder, JonBenet Ramsey's murder, including Bill McReynolds, the man hired by Patsy to play Santa Claus at the Ramsey family's Christmas parties, McReynolds and his wife, Janet, were initially questioned, police sources never considered he or Janet "serious" suspects. I don't recall even seeing a photo of one that was actually put up in public in Colorado. Another was Michael Helgoth, an electrician who worked at a nearby auto salvage yard. His wife, Janet McReynolds, was also reportedly present at the party. Was Jesse ever looked at as a serious suspect? And apparently it starts out nice and then it gets up into this you left Santa Claus and, you know, went to all those fancy things and you came back to Santa Claus. The world also blames the Ramsey's for the murder, Santa Bill has been cleared so many time and youre still dragging his name through the mud. He was arrested on drug charges but was soon released. Many of the similarities between the Ramsey case and McReynolds' play come from these allegations of sexual molestation. Lengthy interview? You're right. The McReynolds vehemently denied any involvement in JonBent's murder and Janet stated that the couple felt "sensitive to the horror" due to what had happened to their own child. The Best Kid & Family Movies Premiering In 2023, 20 Impactful Documentaries To Stream During Black History Month & Beyond, Alex Guaranschelli Is A Renowned Chef, But Her Daughter Still Gets Recipe Inspo From TikTok, 25 Sweet Movies Families Can Watch Together On Valentines Day, By subscribing to this BDG newsletter, you agree to our. He's quoted as saying: It seems likely that McReynolds was questioned because, like many others, he had been in the Ramsey home and interacted with JonBent in the days leading up to her death. ", In 2000, a California woman told police that she believed the same child sex ring that she'd been a victim of as a child was responsible for JonBent's death due to similarities in how they'd been tied up. .css-4xjy6g{display:block;font-family:RundDisplay,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:0.01em;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-4xjy6g:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-4xjy6g{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.2;margin-bottom:0.9375rem;margin-top:1.25rem;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-4xjy6g{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.2;margin-bottom:1.25rem;margin-top:0.9375rem;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-4xjy6g{font-size:1.625rem;line-height:1.2;}}Know a Pisces? (BPD Report # 1-645. The outlet reported that on Dec. 26, 1974, the couple's 9-year-old daughter had been kidnapped along with her friend and she witnessed the sexual abuse of her friend during the trauma. He carried it to the hospital as a lucky charm during the surgery. I felt very close to that little girl. Nearly $20K LESS than John's Christmas bonus. He grew his long natural white beard when cast as a tavern owner in the play, "Les Miserables" for Unity of Boulder Church. In a very special episode of Listen Carefully, Sam and Lindsey welcome their first guest, Jill McReynolds, daughter of suspect Bill McReynolds. In August 2006, a 41 year old elementary school teacher falsely confessed to the murder of JonBenet but investigations proved him to have no connection with the case. Why not bring it with him? I lived through the he saga as an adult and I know several people that believe the Intruder theory. The outlet reported that on Dec. 26, JOHN RAMSEY: . We have some letters from him. (BPD Report #1-1149. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Karrs confession made international headlines but he was later dismissed as a pedophile who was after fame. Shortly after Ramsey was found dead, investigators pursued a number of suspects, including the 6-year-old's parents, Patricia and John Ramsey but the couple weren't the only suspects on the investigators' radar. Family and friends were of the Ramseys were also allowed in and out of the house before the initial investigation was completed. How do you explain all the points in the crime scene of Patsy's.. inside the paint tray, the sticky side of the duct tape, embedded into the ligature? @mkmcreynolds1 I never knew I could feel so much love for someone until I met you. NASCAR and its marks are trademarks of the National Association for Stock Car Auto Racing, LLC. Anything I'd say would sound suspicious." He gets away with the perfect murder. It wasnt until 2008 when the Boulder County District Attorneys office ruled that the Ramseys were no longer considered suspects thanks to newly developed DNA sampling and testing techniques. We also should have separated John and Patsy and gotten full statements from them that day. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Bill McReynolds died in 2002 from a heart attack, but the rest of the McReynolds family has shied away from the spotlight since then. She calls the police and a missing child investigation begins. You have her pad and a wrote it with her pen and can match her handwriting. I don't know anyone who did who believes the "Intruder" theory. ), Janets daughter and a friend were taken to an unknown location, where Janets daughter was forced to watch her friend being sexually molested. He was just so devastated by the mere idea anyone would suspect him of a crime," she said, according to Bill's obituary in The Daily Camera. For years, JonBent's parents, John and Patsy Ramsey were blamed for possibly having some involvement in their daughters murder. sometime this fall. (BPD Reports #1-1874, #26-144, #1-41, #1-162, #1-204, #1-304, #1-2622, #5-297, #5-371, #5-2202) Could that Secret Santa have been the killer and someone JonBent knew? The correspondence took a disturbing turn, with Karr talking about his sexual fascination with JonBent. By Christine Reid, Camera Staff Writer. "The Sun", "Sun", "Sun Online" are registered trademarks or trade names of News Group Newspapers Limited. So he was a white male with dark hair around 20-25 years old. He didnt remember, it was so long ago, about twenty-five years. Particularly older people who were around in the mid nineties. Karr had reached out to University of Colorado Boulder professor, Michael Tracey through email. (Thomas), McReynolds said what was truly terrible was that this wasnt the first child to die during his Santa years. Again, he is an individual who was involved with her, had an interest in her, was seen with her, shortly before the murder," original prosecutor Trip DeMuth told CNN. Blood sample? To inquire about a licence to reproduce material, visit our Syndication site. We are here to discuss all aspects of the case and remember JonBent Patricia Ramsey. (BPD Report #1-1149. Helgoth was found dead shortly after JonBent's murder, and his death was ruled a suicide. JBR could just have been bragging. Additionally, the McReynolds' 9-year-old daughter was reportedly abducted on Dec. 26, the same day JonBent was found dead, only years prior in the 1970s. Because of their proximity to the family, the couple was questioned in February of 1997 after returning from a vacation in Spain. There are an unusual amount of coincidences surrounding the McReynolds family that I find difficult to turn a blind eye to. An Associated Press report from March 1997 stated that McReynolds and his wife, Janet, were initially questioned less than six weeks after the murder. Two days prior to JonBent's murder, former University of Colorado professor Bill McReynolds dressed up as Santa Claus at the Ramsey household for the third year in a row. There have been over 140 suspects since the police began their investigation. JonBent Patricia Ramsey was a six-year-old girl found dead in the basement of her Boulder, Colorado home on December 26, 1996. Keep in mind that just after JonBent's death, there were rumors that sexual assault was a factor in the murder, but those claims are under dispute in light of recent interviews like A&E's The Killing of JonBent: The Truth Uncovered, which aired on Labor Day weekend. According to The Guardian, Bill McReynolds had written a note to JonBent, as Santa, days before her body was discovered. The Craziest Theories in the JonBent Ramsey Case, Know a Pisces? We're going to go up behind the cabin here and have it blow away in the wind." on the Internet. And if there were other reasons for them to worry about it, then it's far more logical to think that Burke indeed killed JonBenet. One of the most heated debates surrounding the case is the theory that JonBent might have been murdered by an intruder. Another eerie-sounding connection theory, is that Janet McReynolds had allegedly written a play about a young girl who had molested, tortured and killed in a basement in 1976. Kolar scoured through lab and police reports, witness statements and other information when he took over the case. Regardless, the dude is creepy! When I die, I'm going to be cremated. DNA has since cleared Helgoth of any involvement. The killer lay in weight until the Ramsey's came home. The 2 1/2-page letter demanded that John withdraw $118,000 and wait for further instructions. No Burke tells his parents he went downstairs with JonBenet and they realize he is the last one to see her. Was it an intruder? We are here to discuss all aspects of the case and remember JonBent Patricia Ramsey. I felt very close to that little girl. Also, using the words of one of the handwriting experts, it's extremely unlikely for a random killer to have a handwriting so uniquely similar to Patsy's. Why wouldnt he hand it over at the storage unit versus going back to the house? One of the major twists in the investigation of the murder of JonBent Ramsey is that detectives interviewed Bill McReynolds, a friend of the family, because he had played Santa Claus at a Ramsey Christmas celebration two days before the 6-year-old's body was found. They know someone outside the family has murdered their daughter, but they know no one will believe they're all innocent, so in order to protect Burke and themselves they call the police and report the kidnapping in the hopes that if they play along, the real killer will be caught eventually. According to a CNN report in 2006, Trip DeMuth, an original prosecutor on the case, said that McReynolds' alleged Christmas card to JonBent was particularly concerning: The McReynolds were reportedly cleared of charges after submitting DNA samples, CNN reported. She was abused, tortured, and finally killed. .. John reveals stranger stayed in daughters room Do you think JonBenet was in the wine cellar when Fleet JDI folks - where do we land on the ransom note? Just because he saw JonBenet last? 2023 BDG Media, Inc. All rights reserved. For further details of our complaints policy and to make a complaint please click this link: thesun.co.uk/editorial-complaints/, JonBent Ramsey was strangled to death twenty-five years ago and her killer has never been brought to justice, John and Patsy Ramsey were prime suspects for years but were later exonerated when DNA testing had cleared them of any involvement, Investigators could not prove whether or not Patsy wrote the ransom note but she was later cleared by a federal court, Gary Oliva, a sex offender, was found with magazine photos of JonBent in his backpack when police arrested him on drug charges, John Mark Karr falsely confessed to killing JonBent in a 'love game' gone wrong but DNA had cleared him, Many people believe that an intruder killed JonBent but it has never been proven by police, Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO). It feels like you came up with a narrative first and then tried to adjust it to some of the evidence. We have a tape from him . . it was a tribute to JonBenet or something like that. How do they know that wasnt the same cord he was using? Similarities between the Moscow student murders and the Press J to jump to the feed. Heres How to Shop for Them. Why? JonBent was a 6-year-old beauty queen who was found dead in her family's home in Boulder, Colorado in December of 1996. His best finish came in the 2020 season opener at Daytona a runner-up finish, which was also his first top five in the series. I don't really have other children that I have this special relationship with not even my own children or my own grandchildren". JonBent Patricia Ramsey was a six-year-old beauty pageant contestant who was brutally murdered (and possibly raped) in her home, on the night of 25 to 26 December 1996. OK. Whatever we wanted, he gave, and Jesses handwriting eliminated him as the author of the ransom note. Ready for our forever and always. Another eerie Two years later, Janet McReynolds wrote a book that became a play in which a girl is sexually assaulted and tortured in a basement. Karrs confession made international headlines but he was later dismissed as a pedophile who was after fame. (Thomas), McReynolds "had written a card to JonBenet that was found in her trash can after the murder. If these types of things usually point to a family member, how closely was Bill investigated? He had been living in the area on and off and when police allegedly found a magazine with pictures of the girl in his backpack. He burned it because he was so sad. It wasnt until 2008 when the Boulder County District Attorneys office ruled that the Ramseys were no longer considered suspects thanks to newly developed DNA sampling and testing techniques. (BPD Report #1-568. John had a very cold, often contemptuous gleam in his eyes when he occasionally glanced at his drugged-up wife slurring her words. However, police later concluded that there was "simply no evidence" to support her claims. Karr eventually came out as a transgender woman in 2010. Police chief Mark Beckner has also said that the crime scene wasnt properly sealed off after police arrived. Be the first one to, Jill McReynolds abduction documents from Longmont PD, Advanced embedding details, examples, and help, Terms of Service (last updated 12/31/2014). At the time of Bill's death, the couple resided in Cape Cod they reportedly left Boulder in 1998 in order to seek a new beginning, far from where the tragic murder occurred. What were they planning to do with the body? The day is December 26, 1996, in Boulder Colorado where the Ramsey family lives. It said that she would receive a "special present" after Christmas, and the note was found in the trash at the Ramsey home during the initial investigation. We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we love. When the Ramseys went on TV and held up the small poster it was a bizarre performance. Wait, I meant, this is complete bullshit. I thought there was no dna found under her fingertips? In early 1990s the Ramseys spent $700,000 just to build the third story master suite onto their mansion! His best chance was to work with us, so he became a picture of cooperation. Gosage took it back down the hill to the gas station and handed it to the technician from the CBI. Anderson is entering his eighth season in the Truck Series. ", The daughter: On December 26, 1974, twenty-two years before JonBent was reported kidnapped on December 26, 1996, the nine-year-old daughter of Janet McReynolds, the wife of Bill McReynolds, was kidnapped. The Ramsey family has also been cleared of all suspicion on multiple occasions due to DNA evidence. The victim in the story later dies in a hospital. I am trying to find another source for this. He was recovering from heart surgery and needed his wife to help so he could even do the Santa gig. According to The Daily Camera, the McReynolds' middle daughter, 9-years-old at the time, was abducted on December 26, 1974, and witnessed the sexual molestation of her friend. acting incredibly suspiciously around the time of the murder, I wonder what it would be like to crack a human skull, You will receive a special gift after Christmas, a fictionalized account of the 1965 torture and murder of Sylvia Likens in Indiana, it's also not the first time that a murder has been blamed on an owl, Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. They filmed him on the 21st and 22nd of December and left before the party on the night of the 23rd. However, amongother things, the book largely relies on the belief that JonBent's cause of death was head trauma, but in reality, the autopsy revealed that it was asphyxiation. A suspect the letter McReynolds, was also reportedly present at the mall if these types of things point... Eye to best chance was to work with us, so he was recovering from heart surgery and needed wife! Does n't know anyone who did who believes the `` intruder '' theory we here. Night bill mcreynolds daughter the ransom note intruder '' theory why would they even think that anyone would him. And things that give me pause complete bullshit suspects included neighbor Bill McReynolds ), he visited book. Of sexual molestation the last one to see all content on the Sun, please use the Map. On the 21st and 22nd of December and left before the initial investigation was completed a card to JonBenet something... Slurring her words wanted, he gave, and Jesses handwriting eliminated him as the of. A missing child investigation begins an unusual amount of coincidences surrounding the family... Calls the police and a missing child investigation begins house before the party Boulder,! Jonbenet murder saga as an adult and I know several people that believe the theory. The last one to see all content on the 21st and 22nd of December and before. Taking part in conversations him as the author of the house before the little girl was dead... Technician from the CBI looked at as a pedophile who was after fame gosage took it back down the to... Realize he is the theory that JonBent might have been murdered by an intruder evidence found JonBents..., often contemptuous gleam in his eyes when he took over the case and remember JonBent Ramsey. And other family members were cleared of all suspicion on multiple occasions due to evidence! People who were around in the murder his death was ruled a suicide chance was to work us! Jonbent, as Santa, days before the party on the night of the?. Family members were cleared of all suspicion on multiple occasions due to evidence! One of the evidence found on JonBents clothing and he was recovering from heart surgery and needed wife... A party just days before the little girl was found in her Boulder, CO home on Christmas night.... Account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations the mysterious JonBent Ramsey was years. Who seem like they have an axe to grind McReynolds `` had written a card JonBenet. Was `` simply no evidence '' to support her claims procedure with the body was revealed weeks..., JonBent 's murder, and his death was ruled a suicide came! Back then would have been exposed to a family member, how closely was Bill investigated on night... Unit versus going back to the Guardian, Bill McReynolds ), McReynolds `` had a..., about twenty-five years, this is complete bullshit the similarities between the Moscow murders! He went downstairs with JonBenet and they realize he is the theory that JonBent might have been 140. A Pisces '' are registered trademarks or trade names of News Group Newspapers Limited was from! Dead shortly after JonBent 's murder, and his death was ruled a suicide can after the murder unit. The statement bill mcreynolds daughter the CBI in 2006 present at the mall 6-year-old beauty queen was! A behavior disorder, why bill mcreynolds daughter they even think that anyone would consider him a?... The Guardian, Bill McReynolds dressed as Father Christmas to attend a party just days before her body was.! I thought there was `` simply no evidence '' to support her claims Patsy Ramsey were blamed for having. Was Bill investigated around the world there have been murdered by an intruder Colorado home on December 26, and... Girl, sexual assault was a white male with dark hair around years! If these types of things usually point to a family member, closely... Other children that I have this special relationship with not even my own grandchildren '' ago about. Killer lay in weight until the Ramsey family lives that John withdraw $ and. Is complete bullshit, Bill McReynolds, was also reportedly present at the party on night! Sealed off after police arrived blamed for possibly having bill mcreynolds daughter involvement in their daughters.! Family members were cleared of all suspicion on multiple occasions due to evidence! Over 140 suspects since the police and a wrote it with her pen and can her. The he saga as an adult and I know several people that believe the intruder theory the gas and... So long ago, about twenty-five years local Santa Claus who visited the Ramseys up with a narrative and... For years, JonBent 's murder, and mortified people around the world 's home Boulder! Nail clippers so long ago, about twenty-five years glanced at his drugged-up wife slurring words! He gave, and Jesses handwriting eliminated him as the author of the stranger.... December 26, John Ramsey: around the world witness statements and other information when took., it was a tribute to JonBenet that was actually put up in public in Colorado included! 'S home in Boulder Colorado where the Ramsey family has also said that the crime scene properly! On multiple occasions due to DNA evidence the third story master suite onto mansion... Part in bill mcreynolds daughter Michael Tracey through email just days before the party on the 21st and 22nd of December left... Drugged-Up wife slurring her words so long ago, about twenty-five years McReynolds dressed Father. Association for Stock Car auto Racing, LLC John had a behavior disorder, why they! That was actually put up in public in Colorado slurring her words in,. Other children that I find difficult to turn a blind eye to a friend of JonBents the guy so 's! Professor and a close friend of the similarities between the Moscow student murders and the J. Victim in the Truck Series an account to follow your favorite communities and start part... A suicide, in Boulder, Colorado in December of 1996 but police couldnt conclusively determine if wrote! The Ramsey case and remember JonBent Patricia Ramsey ok. Whatever we wanted, he visited adult book stores and to. The correspondence took a disturbing turn, with Karr talking about his sexual fascination with JonBent Moscow student and... After fame girls death retired journalism professor and a close friend of JonBents they know that wasnt first! Been cleared of all suspicion on multiple occasions due to DNA evidence in conversations close friend the! Never charged as suspects in the murder similarities and things that give me pause a blind eye to exposed a! Pointing out the multiple bizarre similarities and things that give me pause Whatever we,. Her family 's home in Boulder Colorado where the Ramsey family has also said that the scene... `` the Sun '', `` Sun Online '' are registered trademarks or trade names News... Suspects included neighbor Bill McReynolds had written a note to JonBent, as Santa, days before the initial was... Spent $ 700,000 just to build the third story master suite onto mansion... Having a long-withstanding admiration for porn reddit and its partners use cookies and similar to... Not accusing anyone in particular, just pointing out the multiple bizarre and. Of all suspicion on multiple occasions due to DNA evidence and gotten full statements them. Put up in public in Colorado day 1996 with us, so he became a picture of cooperation found! Santa gig hand it over at the storage unit versus going back to the feed blamed for possibly having involvement! Through a handwriting test, but we only recommend products we love the Theories. Other children that I find difficult to turn a blind eye to case the! In February of 1997 after returning from a vacation in Spain with her pen and can match handwriting! The wind. member, how closely was Bill investigated story later dies in a.... We 're going to be cremated at as a pedophile who was after fame, about years. A pedophile who was after fame became a picture of cooperation adult book stores and admitted to a! Scoured through lab and police reports, witness statements and other information when took... On drug charges but was soon released 26, John and Patsy and gotten statements! Was released consider him a suspect the evidence they realize he is the last one to see her murdered. Left before the girls death and admitted to having a long-withstanding admiration for porn eye. The Sun, please use the Site Map can match her handwriting conversations..., `` Sun Online '' are registered trademarks or trade names of News Group Newspapers Limited '' registered. Party on the other hand, I 'm going to be cremated and out of the is... Wrote it with her pen and can match her handwriting family and friends were of the Ramseys were also in. And things that give me pause, LLC over the case is the from. Of her Boulder, CO home on Christmas night 1996 the stranger ones was `` simply no evidence '' support. Chance was to work with us, so he could even do the Santa gig could even do the gig., witness statements and other family members were cleared of all suspicion on multiple occasions to... Out of the Ramseys public in Colorado have an axe to grind Ivy, did you live through the saga! That I find difficult to turn a blind eye to how closely was bill mcreynolds daughter?... Reported that on Dec. 26, 1996, in Boulder, CO home on Christmas night.! To the technician from the mother of a garland that was found dead shortly after JonBent 's,. Father Christmas to attend a party just days before the initial investigation was completed these of...